(1) Aims and Scope
The rapidly expanding field of biology creates enormous challenges for data visualization techniques that enable researchers to gain insight from their large and highly complex data sets.
The international Symposium on Biological Data Visualization (BioVis) is an interdisciplinary event covering all aspects of visualization in biology. The Symposium brings together researchers from the visualization, bioinformatics, and biology communities with the purpose of educating, inspiring, and engaging visualization researchers in problems in biological data visualization as well as bioinformatics and biology researchers in state-of-the-art visualization research.
We invite submissions of original research articles, poster submissions, as well as submissions for data visualization and redesign contests.
We are looking for contributions on all aspects of visualization in biology, from molecular to cell, tissue, organism and population biology. Suggested topics for paper and poster submissions include, but are not limited to:
Genome and sequence data, including genomic variation data
Multivariate omics data (transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolomics, etc.)
Biological networks and pathways
Structures (e.g., protein or RNA structures)
Biological image data, such as microscopy data
Integration of image and omics data for systems biology
Modeling and simulation of biological systems
Neurobiology and developmental biology
Systems and software frameworks
Biological workflows or collaborative processes
Usability of visualization by biologists
Biological atlases and metadata
Processes for interdisciplinary collaboration between biology and visualization.
The topic of the Data Analysis, and Redesign Contests, is the visualization and analysis of complex networks derived from resting-state fMRI (rsfRMI). Such data define networks that possess physical locations, have physical connectivity that differs from physical proximity, and informational or functional connectivity that differs from both physical layout and physical connectivity. The contests focus on how to better represent this data, so as to improve the utility of rsfMRI. For more details see http://biovis.net/year/2014/info/contest
(3) Submission Types and Criteria
The symposium seeks submissions in four categories:
The symposium seeks submissions in four categories:
Papers: manuscripts describing high quality research. Manuscripts accepted at the symposium will be published in the symposium proceedings and will be presented orally at the symposium. Accepted papers will also be eligible for a journal publication, for details see Section 9 below. Example manuscripts include, but are not limited to:
Detailed reports of original research
Description of new systems
Evaluation of existing systems or approaches
Posters: Submissions consist of a brief 250-word abstract and supporting image that summarize the authors’ work. Authors must present a corresponding poster during the designated poster session, and are encouraged to incorporate a demo or video into their presentation. All authors have the opportunity to give a brief oral preview during a plenary “fast forward” session. Example topics include, but are not limited to:
Work in progress and preliminary results
Previously published work from other venues
Visualization challenges relevant to the BioVis community
Data Analysis Contest Entries: Submissions consist of several parts. These include: (1) a 250-word abstract; (2) a 2-page extended abstract describing the problem, your approach and results, suitable for evaluating the extendability of the entry into a full manuscript; (3) up to 4 additional free-text pages, summarizing the contestants' answer to the challenge, and methods/approach for producing the answer; and (4) a presentation (self-running powerpoint, keynote, or movie) demonstrating the approach and/or further explaining the entry.
Supplementary material ranging from runnable demos in virtualbox images, through published manuscripts, is highly encouraged. Submissions dealing with any aspect of the challenge are encouraged. Data Analysis Contest entries could include, but are not limited to:
complete answers to the specific data analysis contest question
partial answers to discrete aspects of the question
tools that address all, or part of the question, or similar questions in the domain
design studies that argue for better representations for the problem, or answer
All accepted entries will be eligible for presentation at the symposium, either as short podium talks, or as data analysis contest poster or demo presentations.
Data Analysis Contest entries deemed to make significant contributions will be invited to submit a manuscript to the thematic series on Biological Data Visualization of the journal BMC Bioinformatics, either as individual submissions, or as collaborative works collecting topically related submissions, at the recommendation of the judges.
By submitting a Data Analysis Contest entry to BioVis, contestants license the submitted materials to BioVis for dissemination and/or use in BioVis promotional materials.
Redesign Contest Entries: Submissions consist of a redesign of a figure selected by the judges along with a 1-page abstract motivating the methodology behind the redesign. The abstract should include:
aspects of the figure identified as needing improvement or clarification
justification of encoding and design choices
justification of any points of departure from the original
The judges will select a winner and runner-up. A subset of selected contestants will have the opportunity to present their redesign in a session during the symposium, and entries that make significant contributions will be invited to submit a manuscript to the thematic series on Biological Data Visualization of the journal BMC Bioinformatics, in collaboration with the Data Analysis Contest. All accepted entries will be eligible for presentation at the symposium, either as short podium talks, or as Redesign Contest poster or demo presentations.
More information about each category of content and the various submission guidelines can be found on http://www.biovis.net
(4) Symposium Format
The symposium will be a two-day single-track event with keynote and invited talks, paper sessions, contest and redesign entries presentation, and posters/demos. Primers acting as tutorial introductions to visualization topics will be provided.
(5) General Expectations (Ethics Guidelines)
At least one author of an accepted submission must attend the conference to present the work. When submitting your paper you will be asked to provide a complete list of authors even when submitting an anonymized version of the manuscript. This is required to avoid potential conflicts of interest when assigning reviewers. Adding additional authors AFTER the acceptance of a paper is unacceptable and will not be permitted.
All submissions will be treated as confidential communications during the review process, so submission does not constitute public disclosure of any ideas therein. Submissions should contain no information or materials that will be proprietary or confidential at the time of publication (at the conference), and should cite no publications that are proprietary or confidential at the time of publication.
Any use of copyrighted material and devices of proprietary nature will be the responsibility of the presenters.
Contestants will also use the contest data in the spirit of academic collaboration and inquiry. The use of patented and proprietary solutions and software will be permitted for demonstrating the results in a forum at the Symposium. However, it is encouraged that the final submission include open-source code distribution and anonymized data to foster academic collaborations.
(6) Review Process
Reviewers from both visualization and bioinformatics communities will be involved in the paper review process. Paper submissions will be evaluated by external reviewers organized by the Papers Chairs, and will be reviewed for novelty and contribution. The review process for the paper track will be optionally double-blind for those who want to submit their work anonymously. When submitting for double-blind reviewing you are asked NOT to include any identifying information in the submission. Otherwise, the review process will be single-blind, i.e. the reviewers know the identity of the authors, but the authors do not know the identity of the reviewers.
Posters will be reviewed for relevance and interest to the BioVis community by the Poster Chairs.
Data Analysis Contest entries will be reviewed for relevance by the Contest chairs. Accepted entries will be invited to present a contest poster or demo at the symposium. Accepted entries will further be peer-reviewed for contribution and technical merit by external reviewers from the BioVis Program Committee, and judged for awards by a panel of experts from relevant visualization and biological domains. Judges will evaluate submissions on criteria including, but not limited to accuracy, visualization or biological contribution, and design and usability, and will select "winning" entries, as well as recommend entries for short podium presentations and for invitation to a special issue of a journal. Entrants should note that accuracy will not be the sole determinant of judging, and that significant and novel contributions to specific aspects of, or sub-problems within the overall problem, will be viewed favorably. Entrants are encouraged to explicitly state their entries' areas of contribution to facilitate appropriate review.
Redesign entries will be judged for design that enhances the narrative and makes good use of visual emphasis.
(7) Important Dates
Paper submission: March 1, 2014
Preliminary notification: April 10, 2014
Revised manuscript submission: May 10, 2014
Final notification: June 1, 2014
Camera ready copy: June 15, 2014
Poster submission: May 24, 2014
Notification of acceptance of posters: June 1, 2014
Data Analysis Contest entry submission: May 1, 2014
Notification of acceptance of contest entries: June 1, 2014
Redesign Contest entry submission: May 1, 2014
Notification of acceptance of redesign entries: June 1, 2014
All deadlines are at 5:00 pm Pacific Time (PDT).
(8) Submission (incl. Supplemental Material and Formatting Guidelines)
Paper submissions can include full-color figures throughout. We encourage the use of digital video to enhance paper and poster submissions, particularly if part or all of the work addresses interactive techniques. Submission of working code and other supplemental material in order to increase the reproducibility of the work is also encouraged. The material for the contest entries should include all of the aforementioned content. It will be however, advantageous to include all material which will convince the reviewers of the specificity and topicality of the offered solutions. When possible, Open Source software should be provided for contest entries.
Links to details and guidelines for preparing a proper submission and supplementary data can be found on http://www.biovis.net. Authors must follow the style guidelines specified therein.
All accepted papers for the conference will be linked on the BioVis website (http://www.biovis.net
) and will be made available through the IEEE Digital Library.
In addition, all papers accepted for the conference will be considered for publication in the thematic series on Biological Data Visualization of BMC Bioinformatics. Decision about acceptance will be taken by the associate editors (i.e., the BioVis papers and publication chairs) and the BMC Bioinformatics section editor. Final notification about acceptance for the conference as well as the journal will be June 1, 2014.
Authors will be required to meet costs required by BMC for open access; BMC can also provide waivers in cases where authors have troubles meeting these costs.
All accepted poster submissions will be made available on the symposium website.
Data Analysis and Redesign Contest entries that are accepted, and deemed to make a significant contribution to the field, will be invited to submit full manuscripts for inclusion in the thematic series on Biological Data Visualization of BMC Bioinformatics.
Papers that resulted from a successful collaboration between researchers from both the visualization and biology communities will be especially rewarded. Reviewers will be queried on the review form with a question "Should we consider this paper for the best paper award? (yes/no/maybe)".
Posters will be assessed for rewards by a judging committee during the poster presentation session.
Data Analysis Contest entries will be rewarded for creating either the best visualization among the competing entries, or for gleaning the most biological insights, and for other valuable contributions as identified by the judging panel.
For Redesign Contest entries, the judges will be be looking for a redesign that enhances the narrative and makes good use of visual emphasis. Focus, clarity and simplicity will be favored over extravagance.
(12) Organizing Committee
Design contest chairs
Industry and fundraising chairs
(13) Steering committee
Larry Hunter, University of Colorado, USA
Torsten Möller, Simon Fraser University, Canada
Jessie Kennedy, Edinburgh Napier University, UK
Nils Gehlenborg, Harvard Medical School, USA
Raghu Machiraju, The Ohio State University, USA
Angela de Pace, Harvard University, USA
rsquo; work. Authors must present a corresponding poster during the designated poster session, and are encouraged to incorporate a demo or video into their presentation. All authors have the opportunity to give a brief oral preview during a plenary